There’s no summer time within the Northeast with lobster rolls. Whereas New Jersey might not boast the identical status as Maine or Connecticut, the state nonetheless is aware of its approach round a sandwich. Do you are taking yours heat and doused in butter? How about chilled and tossed in mayo? Celery or no celery? These New Jersey eating places cater to the less-is-more crowds, in addition to these on the lookout for one thing uber-indulgent. Nonetheless questioning who makes one of the best lobster rolls in NJ? Listed below are 20 spots that can transport you to New England.
1. Offended Archies – A number of NJ Places
This in style North Jersey meals truck is well-known for its crab desserts. Nevertheless, that doesn’t imply it’s best to overlook the lobster rolls. You will discover two varieties at Offended Archies. A calming Maine model that mixes chunks of lobster with a spicy corn mayo. Or a Connecticut-style roll served heat with butter and lemon French dressing. Discover their weekly schedule on their IG web page.
2. Bahrs Touchdown – Highlands, NJ
A visit to Sandy Hook seashore wouldn’t be full with out lunch at Bahrs Touchdown. This NJ staple within the Highlands has a “Jersey” lobster roll on the menu. Did we point out Bahr’s lobster rolls are additionally served with housemade potato chips? The recent lobster salad is a non-traditional mixture of seafood, arugula, tomatoes, celery and mayo. It’s then generously piled onto a toasted brioche bun.
3. BK Lobster – Hoboken, NJ
BK Lobster may need a status with the NYC crowd, however its first Backyard State outpost has already garnered consideration. The menu right here is basically all lobster, on a regular basis. They provide eight (sure, eight), completely different rolls which vary from traditional to straight outrageous. You may get Connecticut or Maine kinds right here and nearly the whole lot else in between. Lobster claws wrapped in 24k edible gold, anybody?
4. Cousins Maine Lobster – A number of NJ Places
Noticed Cousins Maine Lobster down the Jersey Shore? Or perhaps you’ve seen them parked at a North Jersey meals competition. Both approach, this meals truck has developed a cult-like following, which has rather a lot to do with their 2016 look on “Shark Tank.” Fortunately, it’s well worth the hype. For those who don’t thoughts ready in line, each their Connecticut and Maine-style lobster rolls are top-notch and undoubtedly the truck’s finest dishes.
5. Elysian Cafe – Hoboken, NJ
This French bistro-inspired spot is a part of Hoboken’s historical past. Certain, you gained’t be eating on the water however it’s Washington Avenue location is one in every of our favorites for out of doors eating. When the climate is heat, ordering Elysian’s lobster roll is a should. A hefty serving of lobster salad tossed with shallots, celery and herbs is nestled right into a potato bun with shredded lettuce and tomato. On the aspect is an arugula salad and Pommes Frites.
6. Hooked JC – Jersey Metropolis, NJ
Since ghost kitchens have come into existence, this Bergen-Lafayette spot has jumped on the bandwagon. At present, you’ll be able to order Hooked JC and select between two lobster roll choices. Within the Connecticut model, 1 / 4 pound of wild-caught Canadian lobster (claw and knuckle meat) is piled right into a buttered, toasted split-top potato roll. The Maine model clothes the chilled lobster in mayo, herbs and seasonings as a substitute.
7. Jack’s Lobster/Seafood Shack – Edgewater, Montclair and Cresskill, NJ
This in style seafood institution first set its roots down in Edgewater and has since expanded throughout to North Jersey. The fourth storefront in Brief Hills is claimed to be coming quickly. At any of Jack’s areas, diners can discover two iterations of lobster rolls. One served chilly and with mayo. The opposite is heat with butter. Need to make it a platter? You may get do-it-yourself coleslaw, salad or potato chips on the aspect. Or, go all out and order their double meat choice.
8. Klein’s Fish Market & Waterside Cafe – Belmar, NJ
For those who’re in Belmar, look no additional than this seafood market, riverfront bar and waterside restaurant. Klein’s has been in enterprise for nearly 100 years, so you already know they’re the aficionados in terms of recent, locally-caught fish. Right here, they’re utilizing recent steamed lobster as the bottom for his or her lobster roll and mixing it with celery, Previous Bay and a little bit mayo. Each order comes plated with a aspect of spicy slaw and french fries.
9. Lobster Alley – Raritan, NJ
Lobster Alley in Raritan, NJ is for lobster rolls purists. They’re sourcing their seafood straight from Maine and are making their brioche, split-top rolls by hand each morning. Get ‘em wearing both butter or mayo. Make it a meal with a aspect of potato chips and a pickle.
10. Mystic Lobster Roll Firm – A number of NJ Places
Lobster rolls 3 ways? That’s what you’ll discover a Mystic Lobster Roll Firm. This NJ eatery has a number of outposts throughout North, South and Central Jersey—making all of it too straightforward to fulfill that seafood craving. Whether or not you need it Maine, Connecticut or New England-style, you’ll be able to depend on biting right into a third-pound of lobster meat per sandwich.
11. Level Lobster Bar & Grill – Level Nice Seashore, NJ
What occurs when two Level Nice Seashore eating places merge? You get Level Lobster Bar & Grill. Apart from elevated variations of varied seafood dishes, they’ve bought not one however two lobster rolls on the menu. Get it heat on a potato roll and dripping in butter. Or order the chilly model with citrus lobster salad.
12. Proving Floor – Highlands, NJ
Able to dock and dine? The rolls at this waterfront restaurant are filled with chunks of recent lobster meat that’s calmly dressed with mayo, lemon and recent herbs. Diners get two rolls per order, served on toasted brioche buns.
13. Quincy’s Lobster Rolls – A number of NJ Places
With six NJ areas, you gained’t need to trekk far for lobster rolls from Quincy’s. Their classic-style roll contains the path, knuckle, and claw meat on a scorching canine roll. It’s a mash-up of types with mayo, lemon butter, Previous Bay and chives to high it off.
14. Crimson’s Lobster Pot – Level Nice Seashore, NJ
Since its days as a lobster market, Crimson’s Lobster Pot has change into a Jersey Shore landmark identified for its recent, native seafood. A part of their every day catch contains lobsters, which in the end find yourself being ready chilly with mayo or scorching with butter and stuffed right into a roll. Plus, coleslaw and fries come on the aspect.
15. Stern and Bow – Closter, NJ
If the identify didn’t tip you off, Stern and Bow pays homage to the ocean with their American eatery. What you won’t have identified is that they’re treating the standard lobster roll with as a lot finesse as their different upscale entrées. Suppose Connecticut-style, with big chunks of claw meat drizzled with clarified butter. Previous Bay shoestring fries are served on the aspect.
16. Surf Metropolis – Jersey Metropolis, NJ
At Surf Metropolis, you get two lobster rolls basically for the worth of 1. (As for those who weren’t already operating to this JC hotspot.) You may order their rolls chilly with celery and herb aioli or heat with poached Maine lobsters smothered in clarified butter. The potato roll is non-negotiable.
17. The Boil – Jersey Metropolis, NJ
The one Backyard State outpost for this NYC seafood chain simply so occurs to be in Jersey Metropolis. You’d after all be proper to order their Cajun-style seafood boil. Suppose crawfish, crabs and head-on shrimp. However for those who occur to be on the lookout for a unique sort of chew, their lobster roll isn’t to be missed. The sandwich is overflowing with lobster tail meat and is served chilled.
18. The Bonney Learn – Asbury Park, NJ
The Bonney Learn in Asbury Park, NJ prides itself on sustainably procured and regionally sourced seafood and that philosophy extends to their lobster rolls as effectively. This roll takes a traditional split-top scorching canine bun griddled in butter and fills it with complete lobster meat from Maine that’s tossed merely with mayo, thinly sliced celery, lemon juice and dill. All you want is a aspect of fries and coleslaw and also you’re golden.
19. The Yacht Membership – Edgewater, NJ
With terrific views of the Higher West Aspect, The Yacht Membership is the proper weekend or date night time enterprise. Their “well-known lobster roll” lives as much as its identify and appeases each mayo and butter lovers. Tucked right into a brioche bun, hearty items of Maine lobster meat come collectively together with your alternative of herb mayo or herb butter. Previous Bay fried provides the proper punch of taste.
20. Tony Boloney’s – A number of NJ Places
Catch the Lobsta Lure all summer time lengthy at Tony Boloney’s. This behemoth, over-the-top sandwich is not like every other lobster roll on this record. We’re speaking steamed lobster meat, garlic aioli, “bayou” butter, recent and smoked mutz, all completed with celery salt. Purists would possibly need to look the opposite approach.
Have a favourite spot to get lobster rolls in NJ? Tell us within the feedback under!
Major photograph by Sharon McCutcheon